Different Cigar Rating Formats!!!!!

[John51277]

Lalalalalalalala

[Fatman]

Morn'n John, my review format is quite simple really. I simply tape the band from a new/first time smoke to my beer locker...if it sucked, its taped unside-down and I kno not to get another. My written review is also quite simple...LIKED or DISLIKED. I'm a simple man!

[Itsme-Speedy-G]

FJ your rating system is too hard to figued out.......

[amateurke]

FJ, thats the only good way... You like it or not!! :D

[Cigary]

1-5 system works for me. 1 is bad 5 is best Keeps it simple and you can add notes
Pre light
Construction
Burn
Draw
Tasted like,,,,

[RedBeerd]

Morn'n John, my review format is quite simple really. I simply tape the band from a new/first time smoke to my beer locker...if it sucked, its taped unside-down and I kno not to get another. My written review is also quite simple...LIKED or DISLIKED. I'm a simple man!

this is similar to mine

i normally write on the back of the band a number. 1 - 10
10 being i liked it mucho.

i have 2 boxes of bands...ones ill smoke again...and others probably not :piratehook:

[Da Klugs]

I always liked...

yuck
ehh
good
real good
fking good
Top-5

:)

Reviews are so subjective. I always thought that the empirical ones.. 86/100 type of things were silly to place too much weight on. It's a bunch of rolled up weeds that we burn. The mood you are in, where the cigar came from, how old it is, how it was stored, who you are smoking with, what you ate before hand, what you drink with the cigar, what is going on while you are smoking it all have such a huge impact on my enjoyment of a cigar that there are too many variables to really account for in placing a number on an expereince that has any validity to others.

[LkyLindy]

I always liked...

yuck
ehh
good
real good
fking good
Top-5

:)

Reviews are so subjective. I always thought that the empirical ones.. 86/100 type of things were silly to place too much weight on. It's a bunch of rolled up weeds that we burn. The mood you are in, where the cigar came from, how old it is, how it was stored, who you are smoking with, what you ate before hand, what you drink with the cigar, what is going on while you are smoking it all have such a huge impact on my enjoyment of a cigar that there are too many variables to really account for in placing a number on an expereince that has any validity to others.


I like it--I would also add

Smoked while sober
Smoked while drunk
Smoked while having sex--HUH...WTF.........:oops: